Talk about extreme bummer. Physician's Formula Organic Wear mascara is a disappointment for me. I loved PF's blushes, powders, concealers, bronzers.....but those weren't organic. This mascara was running and did not last. It gives an extremely natural look - read: doesn't do anything! There is no clumping, no dried out brittle lashes....but that's probably because it doesn't stay on your lashes. Depress. I have contacted the company, maybe I just had a bad batch, but this stuff was crap. Keep your $8 or whatever it cost.